High Yield Savings Account vs. Cash Management Account
Joy Wallet is advertiser-supported: we may earn compensation from the products and offers mentioned in this article. However, any expressed opinions are our own and aren't influenced by compensation. To read our full disclosure, click here.
Whenever you're looking for a bank account, the first thing that will come to mind is a high-yield savings account. We all want to earn a high interest rate on our money, and while that may be a priority for many, others want a complete suite of financial products in one account. Known as a cash management account, you can enjoy everything from savings to investments under one umbrella. In this article, we explain the pros and cons and take you through the key differences between HYSA and CMA.
Jump To
What is an HYSA?
HYSA stands for High-Yield Savings Account. It's a type of savings account offered by banks and financial institutions that typically offers a higher interest rate compared to a regular savings account. These accounts are designed to help you grow your savings more quickly, thanks to the higher interest rates, but they also come with some restrictions.
Features of HYSA
- Higher Interest Rates: HYSA accounts offer higher annual percentage yields (APYs) than traditional savings accounts. This means your money will grow at a faster rate through compound interest.
- No or Low Fees: Many HYSA accounts don't charge monthly maintenance fees, although some might have minimum balance requirements.
- Easy Access: Unlike longer-term savings or investment accounts, HYSA accounts typically allow you to access your money without penalties. You can withdraw as needed, although there might be certain limitations on the number of transactions per month.
- Safety: HYSA accounts are usually backed by FDIC (Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation) or NCUA (National Credit Union Administration) insurance, which means your deposits are protected up to a certain limit (typically $250,000 per account holder per institution).
- Online and Mobile Banking: Online banks offer Many HYSA accounts, meaning you can manage your account conveniently through online and mobile apps.
- No Risk of Losing Principal: HYSA accounts are generally low-risk because your principal amount is not subject to market fluctuations, unlike investments in stocks or bonds.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Higher interest rates. HYSA accounts typically offer higher interest rates compared to traditional savings accounts.
- Easy access. HYSA accounts offer relatively easy access to your money. You can make withdrawals or transfers when needed, although there may be restrictions on the number of transactions per month.
- No market risk. Unlike investments in stocks or bonds, the principal amount in an HYSA is not subject to market fluctuations.
- No or low fees. Many HYSA accounts do not charge monthly maintenance fees, and some have low or no minimum balance requirements.
Cons
- Lower returns compared to investments. While HYSA accounts offer higher interest rates than regular savings accounts, the returns are still relatively modest compared to potential gains from investments like stocks or real estate.
- Interest rate fluctuations. HYSA interest rates are subject to change based on market conditions. This means your earnings may decrease if interest rates fall.
- Opportunity cost. If you keep a significant amount of money in an HYSA for the long term, you may miss out on potential investment opportunities that could yield higher returns.
- Tax considerations. Interest earned in an HYSA is typically subject to income tax. While it's not a significant drawback, it's important to account for any tax implications when comparing potential returns.
Only company recommended by Bill O'Reily
- Low investment minimum of $10,000
- Free insured delivery of metals
- Over 900+ positive reviews on Trustpilot
- 100% satisfaction guarantee, 7-day full refund
- Lowest price guarantee & no buy-back fees
- Up to $15,000 in free silver on qualified accounts
What is a cash management account?
A Cash Management Account (CMA) is a financial account offered by many financial institutions, including banks, brokerage firms, and fintech companies. It's designed to provide a one-stop solution for managing various aspects of your financial life, including cash, savings, investments, and sometimes even borrowing. CMAs are particularly popular among investors and individuals who want a more holistic approach to managing their money.
Features of cash management accounts
- Integration of Services: CMAs typically combine features of checking accounts, savings accounts, and investment accounts into a single platform. This integration allows you to seamlessly move money between these accounts and access various financial services from one place.
- Higher Interest Rates: Many CMAs offer competitive interest rates on the cash held in the account, often higher than what traditional checking or savings accounts provide.
- Investment Options: CMAs often allow you to invest in a range of financial products, including stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and exchange-traded funds (ETFs). This enables you to manage your investments alongside your cash holdings.
- ATM Access and Debit Cards: CMAs usually come with ATM access and debit cards, making it easy to withdraw cash and make purchases. Some may also reimburse ATM fees or provide fee-free access to a network of ATMs.
- Bill Pay and Transfers: CMAs typically offer bill payment services and the ability to transfer money to and from external accounts, making it convenient to manage your finances.
- FDIC or SIPC Insurance: Depending on the institution, the cash portion of your CMA may be insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) or the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC), providing a level of protection for your deposits and investments.
- No Monthly Fees: Many CMAs do not charge monthly maintenance fees, but it's essential to check the fee structure of the specific CMA you're considering.
- Cash Sweep Options: Some CMAs offer cash sweep programs that automatically invest your idle cash in higher-yielding investment options, such as money market funds or short-term bonds, when you're not actively using the funds.
- Overdraft Protection: CMAs may offer overdraft protection, preventing you from incurring fees if your account balance falls below a certain threshold.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Integration of services. CMAs provide a centralized platform where you can manage multiple aspects of your finances, including cash, savings, investments, and sometimes borrowing. This integration simplifies financial management.
- Higher interest rates. While CMAs are not primarily known for high-interest savings, they may offer more competitive interest rates on the cash portion of the account compared to traditional checking accounts.
- Investment opportunities. CMAs often include a wide range of investment options, allowing you to invest in stocks, bonds, mutual funds, ETFs, and other assets. This can help you grow your wealth over time.
- ATM access and debit cards. Many CMAs come with ATM access and debit cards, making it easy to withdraw cash and make everyday purchases.
- Bill pay and transfers. CMAs typically offer bill payment services and the ability to transfer money to and from external accounts, streamlining financial transactions.
- No or low monthly fees. While some CMAs may charge fees, many offer no or low monthly maintenance fees, making them cost-effective for many users.
Cons
- Complexity. The integration of various financial services can make CMAs more complex than traditional accounts. This complexity may not be suitable for individuals who prefer simplicity.
- Lower interest rates for cash. While CMAs may offer competitive rates, they are not typically known for the highest interest rates on cash savings. If high-yield savings is your primary goal, a dedicated High-Yield Savings Account (HYSA) may be a better option.
- Investment risk. Although CMAs offer investment opportunities, they also come with investment risk. The value of your investments can fluctuate, and there is no guarantee of returns.
- Fees for investment services. Some CMAs may charge fees for trading stocks, mutual funds, or other investment products, which can erode your returns.
- Account minimums. Some CMAs may have minimum deposit or balance requirements, which could be a barrier for some users.
- Tax considerations. Gains from investments in CMAs may be subject to capital gains tax, depending on your investment activity and tax status.
Key differences
Purpose
HYSA accounts are primarily designed to offer higher interest rates on your savings compared to regular savings accounts. These accounts are focused on preserving and growing your cash through compound interest. While some CMAs may offer interest on the cash portion of your account, they often provide lower interest rates compared to HYSA accounts. CMAs prioritize providing a wide range of financial services over high-interest savings.
Features
HYSA accounts are typically straightforward savings accounts with the primary purpose of saving money. They don't offer the same level of integration and services as CMAs. CMAs are more comprehensive, integrating features of checking accounts, savings accounts, and investment accounts into a single platform. They provide a one-stop solution for various financial needs.
Investment options
HYSA accounts do not offer investment options. They are limited to cash savings and are not designed for investment purposes. CMAs often include investment options, allowing you to invest in stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and other financial instruments. They enable you to manage both your cash and investments from a single account.
Transaction capabilities
HYSA accounts typically have limited transaction capabilities. You can make a certain number of monthly withdrawals or transfers without incurring fees, but they are not intended for everyday spending. CMAs usually have more transaction capabilities, such as check writing, bill pay services, and debit card access. They are suitable for everyday spending and financial transactions.
FDIC-insured
The cash portion of HYSA accounts is usually insured by the FDIC, providing a high level of protection for your deposits. CMAs may have FDIC or SIPC insurance for the cash portion of the account, but the investment portion is subject to market risk and is not insured.
Cost
Many HYSA accounts do not charge monthly maintenance fees, but it's important to check for any fees related to exceeding transaction limits. CMAs may have monthly fees, especially if they offer a broader range of services. Fee structures can vary widely, so it's essential to review the terms and conditions.
Suitability
HYSA accounts are primarily for individuals looking to save money and earn interest on their savings without taking on investment risk. CMAs are designed for individuals seeking a more comprehensive financial management solution that includes banking, investing, and potentially borrowing services.
Only company recommended by Bill O'Reily
- Low investment minimum of $10,000
- Free insured delivery of metals
- Over 900+ positive reviews on Trustpilot
- 100% satisfaction guarantee, 7-day full refund
- Lowest price guarantee & no buy-back fees
- Up to $15,000 in free silver on qualified accounts
Who should use a cash management account?
- Busy professionals and entrepreneurs. CMAs are convenient for individuals with hectic lifestyles who want to streamline their financial management. They offer a one-stop solution for managing cash, investments, and spending.
- Investors. If you want to combine your cash savings and investments in one place for easier tracking and management, a CMA can be beneficial. It allows you to access various investment options while keeping your cash readily available.
- Frequent travelers. CMAs often come with features like ATM access, debit cards, and online/mobile banking, making them useful for individuals who travel frequently and need access to cash and financial services on the go.
- Those seeking to simplify finances. If you prefer having all your financial services (savings, checking, investments) under one roof and find value in simplified account management, a CMA can be a convenient choice.
- Small business owners. Business owners can use CMAs to manage both personal and business finances in one account, making it easier to keep track of cash flow and expenses.
- Savers looking for some investment exposure. If you're looking to earn more on your savings than what traditional checking or savings accounts offer but are not ready to dive into complex investment strategies, CMAs provide a middle ground.
- Those comfortable with investment risk. CMAs offer investment options, so they are suitable for individuals who are comfortable with the potential risks associated with investing and want to grow their wealth over time.
Who shouldn't use a cash management account?
- Those with limited funds. If you have very little money to manage or you live paycheck to paycheck, a CMA might not be necessary. Basic checking and savings accounts may suffice until your financial situation improves.
- High-risk investors. If you are a high-risk investor or trader who frequently buys and sells securities, you might prefer a brokerage account over a CMA. Brokerage accounts offer a wider range of investment options and may provide better tools for active trading.
- Those with specialized accounts. If you already have specialized accounts, such as a retirement account (e.g., 401(k), IRA) or a health savings account (HSA), you may not need a CMA for those specific purposes.
- Those with a preference for separating finances. Some individuals prefer to keep their banking and investing activities separate. If you like to have a clear separation between your everyday spending and your investments, a CMA may not align with your preferences.
- Non-U.S. residents. Cash Management Accounts are often offered by US-based financial institutions and may not be accessible or suitable for non-US residents due to regulatory restrictions and tax implications.
FAQs
Should I put all my money in a high-yield savings account?
It might not be wise to put all your money in an HYSA since the interest rate may not keep pace with inflation. However, if you are saving for a specific goal, you can put the money in an HYSA for a specific period of time.
Where can I open a Cash Management Account?
You can open a CMA at any financial firm or brokerage. Most brokerages, including Robinhood offer a CMA.
What are the alternatives to a Cash Management Account?
If a cash management account isn't right for you, consider money market accounts which pay interest like a savings account and have check writing capabilities like a checking account.
Only company recommended by Bill O'Reily
- Low investment minimum of $10,000
- Free insured delivery of metals
- Over 900+ positive reviews on Trustpilot
- 100% satisfaction guarantee, 7-day full refund
- Lowest price guarantee & no buy-back fees
- Up to $15,000 in free silver on qualified accounts
The bottom line
Ultimately, the choice between a High-Yield Savings Account and a Cash Management Account depends on your financial goals and needs. If you want to maximize the interest on your cash savings, an HYSA may be more suitable. Overall, HYSA accounts are a good option for people looking to earn a bit more interest on their emergency fund or short-term savings while maintaining easy access to their money. However, it's essential to compare HYSA offerings from different institutions to find the one that best suits your needs and offers the highest APY with the terms and features you prefer.
If you prefer a more integrated financial management solution with investment options, a CMA might be a better fit. Cash Management Accounts are versatile financial tools that can be beneficial for individuals seeking an integrated approach to managing their finances. Consider your financial needs and whether the advantages of a the accounts outweigh any potential drawbacks.
Joy Wallet is an independent publisher and comparison service, not an investment advisor, financial advisor, loan broker, insurance producer, or insurance broker. Its articles, interactive tools and other content are provided to you for free, as self-help tools and for informational purposes only. They are not intended to provide investment advice. Joy Wallet does not and cannot guarantee the accuracy or applicability of any information in regard to your individual circumstances. We encourage you to seek personalized advice from qualified professionals regarding specific investment issues. Featured estimates are based on past market performance, and past performance is not a guarantee of future performance.
Our site doesn’t feature every company or financial product available on the market. We are compensated by our partners, which may influence which products we review and write about (and where those products appear on our site), but it in no way affects our recommendations or advice. Our editorials are grounded on independent research. Our partners cannot pay us to guarantee favorable reviews of their products or services.
We value your privacy. We work with trusted partners to provide relevant advertising based on information about your use of Joy Wallet’s and third-party websites and applications. This includes, but is not limited to, sharing information about your web browsing activities with Meta (Facebook) and Google. All of the web browsing information that is shared is anonymized. To learn more, click on our Privacy Policy link.
Images appearing across JoyWallet are courtesy of shutterstock.com.
Share this article
